< PREVIOUS ]   [ 1996 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >


Taking daughters to work won't solve self-esteem problems

Published 28-Apr-1996 in the Denver Post
Copyright ©1996 by Ed Quillen. All rights reserved.

On Thursday, I again strived to be an enlightened parent and entrepreneur, much to the dismay of our daughter at home, Abby, who was sipping her morning coffee.

Okay, Abby, listen up, I barked. This is Take Our Daughters to Work Day, and I don't want you to lose self-esteem. So you're going to stay home and work with me.

She started to splutter a protest, but I knew my duty and didn't let her interrupt.

First we've got to get a column written for the Post. Then there are about a dozen people to call for a magazine article we're going to work on. There's about an hour of tedious scutwork where you get to piece out the phone bill. And the office needs cleaned -- you want to start there?

Dad, that's sexist, making me clean while you do the exciting stuff.

But you said writing is real boring work, and cleaning my office can be quite interesting, especially if you've been studying fungal growths in biology.

Abby offered her usual reply. Dad, it's 'Take your daughter to work day,' not 'Put your daughter to work day.'

But what are you supposed to do? I asked. Just sit there and look over my shoulder, I guess. I can't write with somebody looking over my shoulder, and so I can't do my usual work with you around, and that defeats the whole purpose, doesn't it?

Abby agreed. School's a lot easier than work, anyway. She further observed that since she's the only one in the household with an outside job, maybe she should ask her employer about Bring your parents to work day.

It might be good for you, dad, she explained. Nobody ever yells at you for being five minutes late, or tells you how to dress for work, and you can swear and smoke and belch all you want to while on the job -- you ought to find out how the rest of the world works.

I told her I'd been there and done that, and I asked her if there was any merit to the logic behind Bring Your Daughters to Work Day. The theory is that girls get less attention in school, and they lose self-esteem in adolescence, and if they get a special day in the workplace, then they'll get mouthy in class, just like boys, and do better in school and all that.

But girls already do better in school, Abby pointed out. We don't drop out as much as boys do, more of us go to college, we get higher grades -- I don't know how they can say that schools work against girls.

But what about math? I asked. I was in an accelerated math program in junior high and high school. When we started with eighth-grade algebra, it was about evenly mixed. But by my senior calculus class, it was all boys. The girls who dropped out along the way were pretty smart -- there's got to be a reason.

Abby noted that You were always worried about that, so you threatened to chain me and Columbine in the cellar, feeding us nothing but bread and water, if we didn't go all the way through on math.

Well, as a parent, you do what you must. Abby did agree that many girls lose self-esteem at the onset of adolescence, but that's hardly our fault. Look at any magazine for teenage girls.

So I did -- an old issue of Young & Modern. Its scented and colorful pages teemed with articles like How to attract an awesome hunk, Getting an even suntan so guys will flock to you and Are you a good kisser?

In short, the goal of a teen-aged girl is to attract a teen-aged boy, not to ace a calculus test.

Further, the magazine's theme is that the typical teenaged girl is ugly and repellent unless she invests in the proper perfume, cosmetics, nail polish, clothes, etc.

The whole idea is to get you to think you're repulsive the way you are, Abby said, but you'll be cool and popular if you just buy all this stuff that most girls can't afford. So of course we'll have self-esteem problems. These magazines are in business to give us self-esteem problems, which we can cure by spending a lot of money on Cover Girl cosmetics, Jordache jeans, Calvin Klein fragrances, Maybelline lipstick, Studio Line gels, whatever.

There must be billions of dollars invested in promoting poor self-esteem in teen-aged girls, I said. It's a huge industry. Make girls feel inadequate, and ten sell them some temporary feelings of adequacy with the right clothes or cosmetics.

The Ms. Foundation folks can take daughters to work all they want to, Abby said, but until they burn every copy of those magazines, teen-aged girls will still feel inadequate. All the forces of Madison Avenue and Wall Street are organized to make us feel inadequate, and nothing's about to change that.

She took off for school, and I told her to kick some serious butt on her calculus test. But first I thanked her for coming to work with me to produce a column.


< PREVIOUS ]   [ 1996 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >