< PREVIOUS ]   [ 2000 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >


The GOP's big tent is getting too big to suit some people

Published 27 February 2000 in The Denver Post
Copyright ©2000 by Ed Quillen. All rights reserved.

This McCain Democrat phenomenon -- sane people who normally wouldn't be caught within shooting distance of Republicans suddenly participating in GOP caucuses and primary elections -- seems to be contagious.

Here in Chaffee County, we've just seen the emergence of DeLuca Democrats. We've got an incumbent Republican county commissioner, Frank McMurry, a rancher who's seldom met a development he didn't like. He's up for re-election this year.

A couple of weeks ago, a Salida businessman named Joe DeLuca announced that he would challenge McMurry for the Republican nomination. DeLuca gave several reasons for running, like seeking a more diversified local economy and more openness in government, but it was his call for improved growth management that captured a lot of attention.

How much attention?

I was talking with a friend one day, a reliable Yellow-Dog Democrat. The topic turned to a prominent faction in the local GOP, and I started bemoaning Republican hypocrisy with a rant about people who call themselves conservatives but who have never been known to conserve anything we like about living here.

Be careful here, Ed, he chuckled. You're talking to one of them, now.

As soon as I recovered from the sudden attack of apoplexy, I pressed for details about his conversion. Did he just inherit some money? Discover the joys of golf? Decide to subdivide his property?

Nothing like that. The Republican nomination is just about the election in the county commissioner race this year. The best way to make sure McMurry doesn't get re-elected is to make sure he isn't on the ballot. So a bunch of us changed our party registration so we can go to the Republican precinct caucuses and then the county assembly. And if we can't deny him renomination there, we'll be able to vote for DeLuca in the primary.

This sounded like a lot of work, I observed.

It is, he said, but remember in college when we were marching for and against this and that, and they kept telling us to work within the system? See, we're all grown up now and we're working within the system instead of demonstrating or smashing windows.

Did that party switch also mean that he was going to vote for McCain in the Colorado presidential primary next month?

Well, it's going to be fun to get to participate in the only interesting presidential primary contest in years, but I'm voting for the Shrub, not McCain.

McCain is a conservative Republican, I noted.

Yeah, and he could beat either Gore or Bradley, and hey, I've just changed my registration, not my attitudes. I'll vote for the Shrub because he'll be the weakest Republican candidate. Al Gore would be able to hammer him like an anvil, and I sure don't want a Republican president appointing judges -- Clinton's are bad enough.

That friend wasn't the only DeLuca Democrat. During the next fortnight, just about every registered Democrat or Independent I knew here was telling me about changing registration to Republican and urging me to do the same.

This exercise in party-building hasn't exactly thrilled the local GOP establishment. They've responded in much the same way as the national GOP establishment has to the McCain primary campaign, with complaints that the wrong kind of people are participating, and so the purity of the Republican Party is threatened.

But this sounds a little hollow coming from Bush supporters. The state parties wrote the rules about who could participate in the primaries, and Bush knew what the rules were, and could have campaigned accordingly in New Hampshire and Michigan.

He didn't. And when you read the comments from the Bush camp, it sounds as though there was a script, with firewalls erected in South Carolina and Michigan by Bushies in high places to insure that the script would be followed.

Perhaps we're seeing the limits of insider political manipulation. It all comes down to voters, and this year, voters seem to want to have a say in who gets the nominations.

That's kind of exciting, to see real contests rather than the customary coronation of whoever has the most money and endorsements. On the other hand, it is rather depressing that this happens so rarely that when it does happen, it's big news.


< PREVIOUS ]   [ 2000 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >