< PREVIOUS ]   [ 2000 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >


Modern patriotism: spin for the historically challenged

Published 4 July 2000 in The Denver Post
Copyright ©2000 by Ed Quillen. All rights reserved.

With Independence Day approaching, and with some correspondence at hand which accused me of holding unpatriotic attitudes, I figured some improvement might be in order. As I often do when I don't know where else to turn, I called my favorite inside source, Ananias Ziegler, media relations director of the Committee That Really Runs America.

Ziegler started by explaining that I lived in the wrong part of the country to be truly patriotic. According to our studies, which cover everything patriotic from military enlistments to the proclivity to elect wholesome God-fearing Republicans, the two most patriotic regions are Utah and the old Confederacy, he said.

But those are the only two regions that ever engaged in armed conflicts against the United States, I objected, noting the Mormon War of 1856-57 and the Civil War of 1861-65.

That's one of your problems, Ziegler said. You know too much history to be truly patriotic in any way that would get the approval of the Committee. If you really loved your country -- well, would you hire a private detective to dig into the background of your spouse? Is nosing around in someone's past the act of a loving person? Doesn't your country deserve the same consideration?

I could see his point. As Bob Dole once said, certain overzealous historians might cast doubt on the nobility of America, and that's certainly no way to encourage patriotism.

Ziegler interrupted my musings. Another important aspect of contemporary patriotism is the flag.

Of course. It is the national symbol, and should be respected.

One acceptable patriotic way to display that respect, Ziegler said, is to use the flag to draw attention to your enterprise. If a used-car dealer puts up a string of gaudy flashing lights to attract notice, he might violate an oppressive sign code. But if he flies a huge 40-foot flag, he's being a good patriotic American, and of course, it's merely a coincidence that the flag draws attention to his car lot.

Glad that he had cleared that up for me, I asked about other flags.

That depends, Ziegler noted. If you're in Miami and standing in the street waiving a Cuban flag while protesting the actions of the United States, then it means you're extremely patriotic and American politicians should cater to you, lest they be accused of being unpatriotic.

This was confusing, and it got worse. And if you're anywhere south of the Mason-Dixon line, Ziegler continued, and you display the Confederate battle flag, that's another indication of hard-core patriotism, and again, American politicians will leap through hoops to cater to you.

I recalled Sen. John McCain recently apologizing for his equivocation about the Confederate flag in South Carolina earlier this year.

That just goes to show you how unpatriotic it was to like McCain, Ziegler said. Talk about a tough spin job. Here we've got this decorated veteran with a sense of honor and a sense of humor, spent more than five years as a prisoner of war, a lot of that under torture -- and we made it unpatriotic to support him.

That was an impressive spin job, I agreed, and I asked Ziegler if he could explain how the Committee did it. At first, he demurred, saying this operation was as proprietary as the Microsoft plan for world domination, but eventually, I got him to talk.

It was simple, Ziegler finally boasted. We just tied McCain to the Biased Liberal Media. Everybody knows that you're a bunch of unpatriotic left-wing jackals, and so anybody that gets good press must be a threat to the American way of life.

That would be the ability to buy elections, I foolishly wondered aloud.

See what I mean, Ziegler said, then continued. Now we're positioning the Shrub as the great patriot, even if his Vietnam service consisted of being in a Guard unit for the well-connected. And we've got another big spin problem.

What was that?

At the start of 1999, it was an act of noble patriotism, as expressed by the Republicans in Congress, to want to make Al Gore president, Ziegler explained.

And now the Committee has to make it sound unpatriotic to want Gore to be president, I interjected.

Precisely, Ziegler concluded. Now you see why it's unpatriotic to know about anything that happened before last week.

AN UPDATE: The day after the Sunday column was written, Salida Mayor Jaime Lewis decided that Salida could have July 4 fireworks after all, being as we finally got some rain in this millennium.


< PREVIOUS ]   [ 2000 Index ]   [ Ed Quillen HOME ]   [ SEARCH ]   [ NEXT >